Femur fracture in a paediatric patient with hereditary hyaline fibromatosis syndrome
- Hannah Louise Morley ,
- David L Shaw and
- Gary Hannant
- Trauma and Orthopaedics, Bradford Royal Infirmary, Bradford, UK
- Correspondence to Hannah Louise Morley; hannah.morley1@nhs.net
Abstract
An 18-month-old girl with hereditary hyaline fibromatosis syndrome (HHFS) and fixed flexion contractures presented with an oblique femur fracture, following a fall out of her mother’s arms. The fracture was abutting intramedullary hyaline lesions. Due to her condition, balanced traction was impossible to apply. The authors report effective treatment of her injury using a non-operative approach in an early hip spica, over a 4-week period. There was no evidence of delayed osseous healing. Early spica application could be used as a definitive management option in children with femur fractures and fixed flexion contractures in future. This case emphasises the need for preventative measures to support bone health in patients with HHFS.
Background
Hereditary hyaline fibromatosis syndrome (HHFS) is an extremely rare autosomal recessive disease. It is characterised by the deposition of amorphous hyaline material in the viscera, skin and skeletal systems.1–3 The exact prevalence is unknown. The mainstay of treatment is currently symptomatic only.1–5
Mutations in the ANTXR2 gene are involved. ANTXR2 is involved in making proteins, which interact with components of the extracellular matrix. This pathway is ultimately involved in strengthening connective tissues. It is unclear why individuals present with varying severities of HHFS. Indeed, a diagnosis in infancy carries a poorer prognosis, and, in some cases, can be fatal. Mortality in childhood is often preceded by recurrent chest infections.1 2
Symptomatically, hyaline deposits can cause pain as well as complications from organ dysfunction. In more severely affected individuals, deposits in the intestines can lead to severe diarrhoea and cause failure to thrive. This further compromises the patient’s immune system. Specific to the skeletal system, joint stiffness and pain are often reported.1–5 Deformities and contractures are also recorded.5 Osteopenia and osteoporosis are a feature, and osteolysis can also occur at some joint surfaces, most notably at the hips.2–5
Case presentation
An 18-month-old girl with HHFS sustained a right oblique femur fracture after falling out of her mother’s arms when she was being bathed. The height of the fall was estimated to be less than half a metre. Her mother noticed that the child was crying when her right leg was lifted and presented without delay. The family had not noticed any visible deformity to the leg.
The patient had been diagnosed with HHFS on genetic analysis carried out at 2 months of age. She was homozygote for ANTXR2 c.1073dup. At the time of genetic screening, familial counselling was undertaken by paediatric and genetic specialists. At the time of injury, she was not on any medication to improve her bone density.
Her prognosis was described as palliative within 6 months of life due to her presenting clinical features. She had the following HHFS features: skin deposits and deposits in her intestines, which were under investigation when she presented. She suffered from proximal myopathy. This had resulted in an inability to sit up, crawl or walk. She had fixed flexion contractures of both hips and knees, and had been diagnosed with arthrogryposis at birth. She was being fed by a nasogastric tube due to failure to thrive. Additionally, she had already suffered from numerous previous admissions for staphylococcal infections.
The patient was otherwise well on presentation and no other injuries were identified. Non-accidental injury was screened for and ruled out. Her fixed flexion contractures meant that she held her legs in a frog leg position. Due to the severe proximal muscle weakness, she was only able to lie on her back in a bespoke pushchair and had limited or no movements in any of her limbs. She had no other obvious deformities but did have a small bruise on her right mid-thigh. She cried on palpation of her right thigh.
Investigations
An initial radiograph of the right femur was obtained (figure 1). It was difficult to get a full view due to the patient’s contractures, but later views are shown in figures 2 and 3. Radiolucent deposits are present in close proximity to the oblique femur fracture. Additionally, a chest radiograph (figure 4) demonstrates lucent lesions throughout the immature skeleton. Figures 5 and 6 were taken on day 1 in the hip spica. Figures 7 and 8 demonstrate the progress of the fracture healing. Figure 9 illustrates a skeletal survey image performed 18 months prior to the injury. No deposits in the femur are present at this point.
Lateral view of the patient’s right femur; note radiographs were limited by the patient’s fixed flexion deformities.
Flexed view of the patient’s right knee demonstrating hyaline lesions in the tibia.
Further flexed view of the patient’s right knee.
Chest radiograph taken on admission by the paediatric team demonstrating bilateral symmetrical erosions of the distal clavicles and lucencies in both glenoids. These phenotypical findings have previously been documented in the literature.5
Fracture position in bespoke spica, which was applied at day 1 post-presentation. Modified anteroposterior and lateral views.
Fracture position in bespoke spica, which was applied at day 1 post-presentation. Modified anteroposterior and lateral views.
Radiograph (modified posteroanterior) of the right femur at 2 weeks post-injury.
Radiograph (frog leg lateral) at 4 weeks of the right femur in the spica demonstrating good quality callus.
(Frog leg lateral) of the patient’s right femur on skeletal survey 18 months prior to presentation with femur fracture. No lesions visible in femur.
A bone profile on admission demonstrated the following: 25-hydroxycholecalciferol of 43 nmol/L, parathyroid hormone of 8.7 pmol/L, adjusted calcium of 2.53 mmol/L and phosphate of 1.39 mmol/L.
Differential diagnosis
Radiographs demonstrate that the patient had an oblique fracture of the right femur with surrounding features typical of HHFS. It is unclear whether the integrity of the bone was weakened by the presence of HHFS.
Treatment
The patient was treated with a multidisciplinary approach and was under the care of both the paediatric team and orthopaedic team.
An assessment of bone health was made, and she was commenced on cholecalciferol by the paediatricians, with a plan to follow her up and assess whether bisphosphonate treatment would be required.
With regard to the management of the femur fracture, due to the patient having fixed flexion deformities and proximal muscle weakness, in addition to the fracture being in relatively good alignment on presentation, a decision was made not to treat the fracture in conventional traction. The patient was placed in a spica cast within 24 hours of presentation. The fracture was maintained in good alignment in the spica (figures 5 and 6). As such, the patient was treated for 4 weeks in total in a hip spica, and followed up in the orthopaedic clinic and plaster room. Adequate callus was evident on a radiograph taken in clinic at the 4-week follow-up appointment and the spica was removed (figure 8).
Outcome and follow-up
The patient was referred to physiotherapy on discharge. She did not present with any further fractures in a 6-month period. The paediatric team continue to follow her up.
Discussion
HHFS is rare, thus many clinicians are unlikely to encounter this in their clinical practice. However, this should not detract from the key point of the article. Patients with fixed flexion deformities, although from other causes, could be treated in a similar way.
There is very limited evidence in the literature with regard to fracture management in this cohort of patients. The authors were able to find one case report detailing a patient with HHFS who had undisplaced fractures managed non-operatively.4 There are further reports of dislocations in patients with HHFS from massive osteolysis also being managed non-operatively.5 However, the children in these reports were able to self-ambulate.
Osteoporosis and osteopenia are commonly associated with HHFS. Some authors advocate using bisphosphonates as treatment.2 Following the fracture, our patient was treated with cholecalciferol; another option would be to treat with bisphosphonates. As osteopenia is commonly associated with this condition, the authors suggest that a bone health assessment is carried out upon diagnosis of HHFS. Additionally, her parents were unaware of the high risk of fractures associated with this condition. A discussion about bone health is documented in this patient’s notes prior to the fracture; however, the parents are unable to recall this. This highlights that ongoing family education is required in such complex cases, to ensure retention of vital clinical information.
Standard treatment for femoral fractures, such as these, is often in balanced traction for 1–2 weeks followed by conversion to a hip spica. Khoriati et al 6 also detailed this approach. In a recent systematic review, not specific to patients with HHFS, there is no agreed protocol with regard to treating these fractures.7 Traction is described in infants and children who are self-ambulant and often inadvertently displace the fracture. We were unable to find specific guidance on traction in non-ambulant individuals in either the paediatric or adult population. Proximal myopathy in this case meant that our patient was non-ambulatory thus reducing the risk of inadvertent displacement of the fracture. The greatest risk of displacement was during caring activities.
Furthermore, with the fixed flexion contractures present in this particular case, it would have been difficult to adequately apply skin traction. There may have been a possibility of using traction pins to do this; however, this is undocumented in cases such as these.
With regard to surgical management, there were many considerations in our case. These included the patient’s high risk of postoperative infection. She had an already compromised immune system and a known recent staphylococcal bacteraemia. The risk of requiring further surgical intervention is unpredictable, and complications can occur.8 Furthermore, the benefits of surgical management of a non-ambulant patient are reduced when compared with an ambulant child. Technical aspects of operating on a patient with fixed flexed deformities may present practical challenges. Additionally, it is unknown whether fixation is more complex through hyaline deposits in the femur, as they are of unknown density.
The ongoing coronavirus pandemic was undoubtedly a consideration in this patient’s management. Due to the patient’s age at the time of presentation, she had not had a SARS-CoV-2 vaccine and therefore was at additional risk of complications from this disease.9 The patient had already suffered from recurrent chest infections leading to extensive medical treatment. Therefore, an option with the least inpatient exposure was in her best interests. A spica managed as an outpatient offered this option.
Learning points
-
Hereditary hyaline fibromatosis syndrome (HHFS) is a rarely encountered condition, which presents real challenges in managing the sequelae, in such cases, a multidisciplinary approach is vital.
-
Osteoporosis and osteopenia are reported in HHFS. Risk of fracture following low-level trauma should be counselled for and assessed, and preventative measures commenced upon diagnosis of HHFS to prevent fractures.
-
Patients with fixed flexion deformities from other causes could be treated in a similar way, with an early hip spica.
-
In our case, we found no evidence of delayed secondary bone healing in a patient with HHFS, indicating that the unaffected bone heals as one would expect it to.
-
A good plaster room and cast technicians are vital in managing these complex patients and supporting their families.
Ethics statements
Patient consent for publication
Footnotes
-
Twitter @Trauma and Orthopaedics
-
Contributors All of the authors were involved in the treatment of this patient. HLM wrote the article with editing from DLS and GH.
-
Funding The authors have not declared a specific grant for this research from any funding agency in the public, commercial or not-for-profit sectors.
-
Case reports provide a valuable learning resource for the scientific community and can indicate areas of interest for future research. They should not be used in isolation to guide treatment choices or public health policy.
-
Competing interests None declared.
-
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
- © BMJ Publishing Group Limited 2022. No commercial re-use. See rights and permissions. Published by BMJ.
References
Use of this content is subject to our disclaimer